2026-10-11T19:13:13Z
https://api.figshare.com/v2/oai
oai:figshare.com:article/33974674
2026-09-23T17:21:38Z
category_7
category_19
category_21
category_64
category_106
category_132
portal_5
item_type_3
month_year_09_2026
<p>Preprocessing script.</p>
Jan-Ole Hesselberg (21453807)
Pål Ulleberg (522303)
Øystein Sørensen (4767861)
Knut Inge Fostervold (11509353)
Sigrid Hegna Ingvaldsen (15359171)
Ida Svege (11509356)
Medicine
Pharmacology
Biotechnology
Cancer
Science Policy
Infectious Diseases
general panel membership
average iccs ranged
human judgment rather
structured review formats
stable reviewer tendencies
reviewer age composition
moderate across funders
substantially improve reliability
systematic reviewer characteristics
including reviewer similarity
depth review procedures
matter expertise rather
examines factors associated
slightly lower disagreement
reviewer similarity
review depth
specific rather
review roles
multiple factors
four funders
reliability persist
rater reliability
lower disagreement
application characteristics
yet concerns
variability arose
temporal trends
specific ambiguity
reviewers selected
reviewers disagree
residual level
research area
registered report
rater agreement
program features
primarily due
leveraging data
level ambiguity
inherent variability
greater responsibility
grant evaluations
expert reviews
clearer criteria
assessments conducted
also associated
absolute magnitude
1 percent
<p>This script has been used for producing the primary data set used as the basis for the analysis script (see <a href="http://www.plosone.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pone.0356108#pone.0356108.s005" target="_blank">S2 File</a>). This includes merging the data sets from the four funders and producing the explanatory variables based on variables that could be used to identify reviewers or applications (gender and birth year). Additionally, all application IDs and reviewer IDs are switched with anonymized IDs.</p> <p>(TXT)</p>
2026-09-23T17:21:34Z
Dataset
Dataset
10.1371/journal.pone.0356108.s004
https://figshare.com/articles/dataset/_p_Preprocessing_script_p_/33974674
CC BY 4.0